Debt counseling and frugal living

[ Bookmark this page! ] [ get HTML Version ]

Debt relief - Your road to debt relief
Living with debt is not something someone hopes for, but it happens and it usually becomes far more severe than it should before something is done to eliminate it. Once many individuals realize they have a problem with debt, they are too embarrassed to ask for help so they let themselves dive further into debt. Being embarrassment and ashamed are regular emotions many encounter when they realize t... Read debt consolidation article



Debt reduction - Setting a budget
Most people avoid budgets like the plague. When mentioning a budget I've heard comments such as, "Isn't that for retired folks?", "There's no way I can stay on a budget!" and "A budget feels so limiting, like a diet: you see something you want and can't have it because of guilt, shame and restrictions". Yet we all know that restricting our food intake causes weight loss and restricting our spendin... Read debt consolidation article



Debt counseling and frugal living
The opportunities for spending money nowadays are unlimited. Too many people find themselves too strapped to pay their bills on time and complain when their bi-weekly salary is paid a couple of days late. Living on the edge is frustrating, stressful and completely unnecessary. No matter how much or how little money you make, good spending and saving habits can solve your problem.

"A penny saved is a penny earned" is a saying that can be applied toward many situations. With diligent research and patience, second hand furniture can be found at one third the price of new. The trick is to keep looking until you find almost exactly what you want. Prudence dictates that the higher the quality, the better the furniture will look and the longer it will last. Classic styles will never go out of fashion and you can sell your old furniture to defray the cost of the replacement. Make sure your old furniture is polished, empty, and shown to good advantage.

Make your meals at home interesting and romantic. Eating out should be a treat saved for a special occasion or enjoyed once in a while when far away from home. Car trips, excursions to the country, or times when you know you will be away from home for a long period of time are situations that require some forethought in the food department. Bring an apple or a bag of fruit to assuage your hunger until you get home. Remember that the cost of dinner for four at a nice restaurant can feed the family for a week.

Some large department stores welcome returns. Their generous return policy has proven a boon to their bottom line, bringing more people more often into their stores. You may return any item you bought at their store for a full refund, even though that refund may be in the form of a store credit. This credit can now be applied toward clothing, appliances, or any needed item that they sell. A garage sale would price these returns at ten cents on the dollar instead of at full retail value. Clothing department stores often double up on coupons and discount sales. That is the time to buy your annual clothing needs, not at the last minute when you need something new to wear. Holiday presents can be bought at any time during the year and put away until needed.

Another quicksand trap is the purchase of excessive insurance. Insurance agents can reel off numerous reasons why you need more insurance just to line their pockets with more money. Statistics can be bent to say almost anything so don't fall for their pitch. Insurance for catastrophic events is necessary but to cover the replacement cost of one hundred percent of a loss is wasteful. Term life insurance is the biggest culprit. Plan your insurance needs carefully and sparingly for complete peace of mind.

Everyone has a hobby or an expertise in some area. Put your hobby to work with an ad in the paper and network your talents to acquaintances. If you are renting, consider buying a small home and use your rent money to pay off your mortgage. In time, your equity in your house will bring great rewards.

Vacations can cost a lot of money, all out of proportion to the enjoyment received. Cruises, time shares, fancy hotels and first class accommodations can triple the cost of your vacation. A hotel off the beaten track, an exchange of houses with a friend living in another part of the world, a car trip, or just a couple of weeks at a mountain resort can supply you with a great, fun-filled vacation for a reasonable amount of money.

Finally, always pay the minimum or more on your charge accounts to avoid interest charges. With all this money you are saving, be sure to place some of it into a saving account. Regular savings should be treated as a living expense, not a special event from a windfall lucky break. You'll thank yourself later.

Enjoying retirement in New Jersey.

What do you want to do?
Bookmark this page before you lose it
Search this site for FREE information
Help spread the word. E-mail this page to a friend

Bankrupt Your Student Loans

Everyone knows that you cannot bankrupt student loans. Search the web with the keywords "bankruptcy" and "student loans" and you get either many listings for lending institutions trying to get you to take out another loan, or you see articles telling you that it is virtually impossible to bankrupt your student loans except under the condition of "undue hardship" and then they fail to tell you anything how to go about proving the condition. How frustrating!

Below is a summary of the salient points given in Bankrupt Your Student Loans and Other Discharge Strategies by Chuck Stewart, Ph.D. (ISBN 0-9764154-5-3). Here is an author who has been through the process, successfully bankrupting $54,000 in student loans, and has written a clear, step-by-step, instruction manual to help other honest debtors in their efforts to have their student loans discharged through bankruptcy or Compromise or Write-Off.

The bankruptcy courts originally treated student loans the same as any other unsecured debt. Student loans could be listed in a Chapter 7 filing and fully discharged. However, in 1976 Congress modified the Higher Education Act of 1965 and required student loans to be nondischargeable unless: (a) the debt first became due more than 5 years before the date of filing of the bankruptcy, or, (b) failure to discharge the debt would cause "undue hardship" to the debtor or to dependents of the debtor. In 1990, Congress extended the 5 year rule to 7 years and eventually eliminated the time limit altogether in 1998. Thus, the only option debtors currently have for bankrupting their student loans under 11 U.S.C.A. Bankruptcy Reform Act (1998) §523(a)(8) is to prove repaying their student loans would cause an "undue hardship."

"Undue Hardship" Analysis

Unfortunately, Congress failed to define the term "undue hardship." A review of the discussion and debate by the legislature regarding the education amendment is unrevealing as to the meaning of undue hardship. Thus, it has been left up to the courts to determine its meaning. Aggressive defense by Department of Education attorneys has influenced the court to a decidedly rigid interpretation. In general, for a debtor to qualify for an undue hardship discharge of student loan debt, the debtor must be living at, or below, the Federal Poverty Guideline and have no hope for increased future income substantial enough to make payments on the loans.

Over the past quarter-century, courts have developed many tests to determine the existence of undue hardship. The leading test used in most court is the Brunner Test. Other tests include the Bryant Poverty Test, Totality of the Circumstances Test, and the Johnson Test. A review of these tests locate some common characteristics used by courts to determine undue hardship. These include:

Characteristic A. An evaluation of the debtor's current living condition and the impact that has on the ability to repay the loan while maintaining a "minimal living" standard.

Characteristic B. The debtor's future prospects for repaying the loan.

Characteristic C. Evaluate whether or not the debtor demonstrated good faith during loan repayment.

There are two steps involved to demonstrate Characteristic A

1. Every court reviews the debtor's current living condition and evaluates it against the Federal Poverty Guidelines. Debtors with incomes above poverty will be scrutinized by the courts to assure all expenses are "minimized." Expenditures will be compared to an idealized debtor of similar situation but at the official poverty level.

2. Once the court is satisfied the debtor has minimized living expenses, the court evaluates whether repaying the student loans will push the debtor down to or below the poverty level.

Characteristic B is impossible to predict. Courts have recognized the folly in trying to predict future income, but it has not stopped them from including it in their analysis. Courts have considered many factors that may affect future earnings including personal limitations such as: (1) medical limitations, (2) support of dependents (and their medical conditions, if applicable), and (3) lack of useable job skills. Courts have also considered some external factors such as age discrimination (for debtors over age 50), having been labeled a whistleblower, and other social and cultural factors that affect the ability to obtain gainful employment.

Congress was most concerned with debtors who seemingly defrauded the government by bankrupting their student loans soon after graduation. To reinforce that concern, courts want debtors to demonstrate good faith attempts at repaying student loans. Characteristic C, Good Faith, means that the debtor must show that he or she made payments on student loans whenever his or her income was above the poverty level, or, when there was insufficient income, he or she obtain deferments or forbearances to keep the loan in good standing.

Income Contingency Repayment (ICR) Plan

Even if a debtor clearly demonstrates that the undue hardship analysis applies to his or her case, the Income Contingency Repayment (ICR) Plan may unravel the case. The ICR allows student loan repayment to increase or decrease according to the income of the debtor. As such, if the debtor's income is below the Federal Poverty Guideline, then the payment drops to zero. The plan lasts for 25 years and any outstanding debt is discharge. However, the loan discharged amount is treated as income by the IRS and income taxes will be due.

It is often stated by Department of Education attorneys that ICR makes it impossible for debtors to discharge their student loans in bankruptcy. They contend that anyone can make zero dollar payments, thus negating the undue hardship exception of §523(a)(8). In many cases this is true. But for some debtors the ICR is inappropriate. For example, imagine being 65 year or older living on SSI or on a fixed income and then a large tax liability descends upon you for debt discharged at the end of an ICR plan. That would place an undue hardship upon you. In fact, the ICR is really inappropriate for anyone over the age of 40 because of the tax liability at the end of the repayment period.

Regardless, debtors planning an adversary proceeding must prepare a robust response to the Income Contingency Repayment Plan.

Filing the Bankruptcy and Adversary Proceeding

Student loans are listed in the Chapter 7 bankruptcy as one of the outstanding debts held by the debtor. The debtor must then file an Adversary Proceeding in conjunction with the Chapter 7 bankruptcy case within 60 days of the meeting with the creditors. The adversary proceeding is against the Department of Education (or other guarantee lender) and asks the court to determine if the undue hardship clause applies. If the court decides §523(a)(8) applies to the case, then the student loans are discharged through the Chapter 7 bankruptcy.

There is research to show that debtors who file their own Chapter 7 bankruptcy and adversary proceeding prevail more often than if an attorney is used. Most attorneys will not touch an adversary proceeding on student loans, and those that do, want at least $5,000 up front with additional high hourly fees. You know your situation best and it is suggested that you try to do this yourself. Even if you retain an attorney, you will have to perform most of the financial research needed to prove undue hardship. If you do file your own case, you may want to retain an attorney or paralegal to help with some of the steps, forms, or language.

Here is where strategy comes into play. You really do not want to go to trial. In a majority of cases, the debtor loses. In Bankrupt Your Student Loans and Other Discharge Strategies, a chapter is devoted to an analysis of court cases. Often courts give irrational responses and rule against debtors with clear cases of hardship. Most courts analyze the debtor at the Federal Poverty Level whereas a minority of courts performs the same analysis at a middle class income level. Because Congress failed to clearly define undue hardship, the courts have ruled all over the place; and there is no consistency even between courts using the same test.

The better tactic is to settle out of court with the Department of Education or renegotiate the loan and stipulate that to the court. For example, you could convince the Department of Education to accept 10 cents on the dollar as banks often do with bad debt. Say a $60,000 loan is reduced to $6,000 paid over 5 years (i.e., $50/month) with the remaining $54,000 discharged through the Chapter 7 bankruptcy. By discharging the debt through bankruptcy, there is no income reported to the IRS with no resulting income tax. You and the Department of Education create a Stipulation to the new repayment plan and submits it to the court for approval without trial.

Debtors need to prepare like they are going to trial. Each of the Characteristics and ICR discussed above must be addressed in full. It is not difficult work, just detailed and tedious. It is advisable to create worksheets to systematically organize financial details and write, in your own words, responses to each item. Research will be needed to obtain current financial guidelines for the Federal Poverty Level and typical expenditures for similarly situated debtors reported by the IRS. This research helps to establish that you have not been negligent in your spending. Bankrupt Your Student Loans and Other Discharge Strategies has created a systematic approach to proving undue hardship with the use of worksheets, sample forms, and extensive Appendix. By gathering all these materials together, you will be able to aggressively negotiate with the Department of Education before the trial. Hopefully, you will succeed and avoid a judge making the final decision.

It is impossible to write in general terms about how the adversary proceeding will proceed. Each court is different and each case is different. However, like with other civil complaints, there are usually the following steps:

Filing the Complaint with Proof of Service
Status Hearing
Mediation
Pre-Trial Hearing
Trial

It is before the Mediation that you present your case to the Department of Education. This is your opportunity to try and renegotiate your loan: including having it completely discharged. More often than not, the attorney for the Department of Education will play hardball citing the ICR as the reason you cannot prevail with the undue hardship argument. You continue to negotiate with the Department of Education after the Mediation and address those questions that came up during the Mediation. In many cases, they will accept the offer if it is reasonable rather than risk losing at Trial.

Even in situations where debtors do not file bankruptcy, there is the opportunity to have student loans discharged through the little known processes of Compromise or Write-Off. Instead of filing suit and having the case decided at trial, the debtor negotiates directly with the Department of Education to discharge the loan. Why would they do this? It costs money to keep dead loans in the system. Also, there are government directives allowing the Department to discharge loans through Compromise or Write-Off. Regardless if a bankruptcy or Compromise or Write-Off is planned, the process of proving undue hardship remains the same.

The above article was a brief summary of Bankrupt Your Student Loans and Other Discharge Strategies by Chuck Stewart, Ph.D. (ISBN 0-9764154-5-3). It is the only book to give step-by-step instructions for filing and arguing an adversary proceeding to discharge student loans through bankruptcy. It is written in plain English, with a minimum of legalese, and can be purchased directly from www.StewartEducationServices.com or from Amazon.com.

Chuck Stewart, Ph.D.


Top rated articles for debt consolidation

1. Credit Card Debt Elimination
Credit card debt elimination can be done with a good plan and a little patience. The important thing is to find what works best for you and stick to your plan. The rewards are well worth it and you'll... Read debt consolidation article

2. How to resolve your debt
In the last section we covered your rights against harassment and abuse by collectors. We also covered some options that your creditor may have to help you resolve your delinquent debt. Again I repeat... Read debt consolidation article

3. Good debt versus bad debt - What you must know
Debt has been a part of every body's life and personal debt gradient is on the rise because credit hasn't been easier to receive. In everyday life, most of us would not have enough finances in one go ... Read debt consolidation article

4. Consolidate your credit card debt
With the popularity of plastic money these days, credit cards are gaining immense importance. With growing usage of credit card the number of people in debt and the amount of debt for each of them is ... Read debt consolidation article

5. Credit Card Terms and Conditions
It's sad but today most credit card companies are devious and they've designed everything possible into the fine print of their terms of service to catch you. Therefore, when looking at any credit car... Read debt consolidation article

6. Debt free with debt consolidation loan
If you have multiple debts, and are struggling to meet the monthly payments, then there's a good chance you will want to consider, now or later, a consolidation loan to become debt free. If... Read debt consolidation article

7. How to knock down debts and repair credit
If you take a hard look at your situation and analyze your debts carefully, you might just find a solution to knocking down the debts. Debts are bills we owe to creditors, someone or source that has e... Read debt consolidation article

8. Debt management company
Debt is a word not liked by many, but the cold reality of life for most Americans. Many people face debt, in different forms and at different times of their life. Some are better at dealing with the s... Read debt consolidation article

9. Credit Card Debt Consolidation Tips
The Forms of Debt

When you can't pay the total of your bills every month or when you miss a payment, then you have officially joined the ranks of almost half of Americans who are in debt. D... Read debt consolidation article

10. Credit Counselor - Asking The Right Questions
When you find yourself thinking about using a credit counseling service, you need to be very careful. You need someone who will help you, not just some pushy sales associate who wants only to sign you... Read debt consolidation article

1. Debt management fees and pricing - How to compare the debt management plans
2. Bad Credit Debt Consolidation Advice
3. Debt management tips
4. Debt consolidation - How to cut your monthly outgoing
5. Basics of Debt Consolidation
6. All about unsecured and secured debt
7. Debt Management Services - Professional Help
8. Out of Credit Card Debt in 3 Simple Steps
9. Debt Consolidation To Solve Your Debt Problems
10. Debt relief - Why most detb consolidation programs fail

Debt consolidation, debt counseling and debt management in Alabama, Alaska, Arizona, Arkansas, California, Colorado, Connecticut, Delaware, Florida, Georgia, Hawaii, Idaho, Illinois, Indiana, Iowa, Kansas, Kentucky, Louisiana, Maine, Maryland, Massachusetts, Michigan, Minnesota, Mississippi,



Debt counseling and frugal living
Debt consolidation, debt counseling and debt management services in Missouri, Montana, Nebraska, Nevada, New Hampshire, New Jersey, New Mexico, New York, North Carolina, North Dakota, Ohio, Oklahoma, Oregon, Pennsylvania,

Debt management, debt counseling and debt consolidation in Rhode Island, South Carolina, South Dakota, Tennessee, Texas, Utah, Vermont, Virginia, Washington, Washington DC, West Virginia, Wisconsin and Wyoming.